Sandra Kay Baker, known as Sandy, was 46 when she was last seen on May 25, 2000, in Delaware Township, Pennsylvania. She lived on Folk Road with her fiancé, William Billy Thomas Crea Jr., and the couple had wedding plans for October that year. Crea said he last saw her midmorning at a Sheetz on Route 18 driving a dark blue 1988 Honda Accord with Florida plates, and reported receiving a distressed call from her around 1:00 p.m. in which she said she was in danger and could not come home but would be in touch. A witness later saw her car headed south toward Sharon, Pennsylvania that day.

The vehicle turned up abandoned in the Shenango Valley Mall parking lot the next day but was mistakenly repossessed and sold at auction before police could process it for evidence; the car was not located again until years later. No activity appeared on her bank or credit accounts after she vanished. Attention focused on her fiancé, Billy Crea, who was publicly named a suspect in 2005; a private investigator he’d hired, Clifford Aley Jr., was later convicted of hindering apprehension and told authorities Crea had allegedly confessed to killing and burying Sandy, though her body has never been found.

Did anyone in the Sharon or Delaware Township area know Sandra’s routines or see her Accord on May 25, 2000?