In the city of Puyallup, Washington—a place named for the “generous people” of the Puyallup Tribe and nestled in a fertile valley famous for its annual daffodil festival—the winter of 1996 was marked by severe floods that tested the community. Amid the concerns of a difficult season, another, more personal tragedy unfolded in the early winter darkness, one that remains a painful, unanswered question for decades. The unsolved homicide of Donald Loyde Robbins, a 32-year-old Caucasian man, has left a quiet but persistent void since his life was abruptly taken on December 7, 1996.
That Saturday evening, Donald was at the Daffodil Bowl, a local landmark and bowling alley on East Main Avenue that has been a hub of community life since the 1950s. Patrons at the Daffodil Bowl’s bar would have been enjoying a typical weekend night out, the sounds of bowling balls hitting pins and the low murmur of conversations filling the air.
Donald was among them, spending some of the final hours of his life in this familiar local establishment. What transpired inside the bar, who he may have spoken with, and the exact time he decided to leave remain unclear.
The evening ended in violence just a few steps away. Donald was found dead in the parking lot of the Hungry Goose, a restaurant located at 1618 E Main, immediately adjacent to the bowling alley. He had been struck and killed by a vehicle. The short distance between the two businesses suggests a sudden and brutal confrontation. Whether the incident was a hit-and-run, an argument that escalated with horrific speed, or a deliberate act of murder using a vehicle as a weapon is a question that has haunted the investigation from the beginning.
The Puyallup Police Department’s Criminal Investigations Division took charge of the case. Their work led them to identify a probable suspect, a man named Wayne Collins. Based on the evidence they gathered, investigators arrested Collins in connection with Donald’s death. This moment must have felt like a breakthrough, a step toward justice and providing answers for a grieving, unknown circle of family and friends. However, the promise of a resolution was short-lived. After reviewing the case presented by the police, the prosecutor’s office declined to file formal charges against Collins.
The reasons for the prosecutor's decision have not been made public, leaving a gap in the narrative of the investigation. Without sufficient evidence to proceed to trial, Wayne Collins was released, and the case stalled. For years, the investigation into Donald Robbins' death has remained open but inactive, a file waiting for the one piece of new information that could change its trajectory. It is one of several cold cases on the Puyallup Police Department’s list, each representing a life cut short and a family left waiting.
Decades have passed since Donald Robbins died. The Hungry Goose restaurant has since changed hands and is now the HG Bistro, but the Daffodil Bowl still stands next door, a reminder of the place where Donald spent his last evening. The official record of his death is stark and offers no glimpse into the man he was—his work, his family, his passions, or how his loved ones remember him. His death remains a cold fact in a police file. As of today, the Puyallup Police Department still lists the case as active and encourages anyone with knowledge of the events of December 7, 1996, to come forward. The smallest detail could be the key to finally bringing clarity and justice for Donald Loyde Robbins.