Graig Wayne Anderson Jr., known to friends and family as “Andy,” was a decorated military man and a successful businessman, but his most cherished roles were as a husband, father, and grandfather. Born in Columbus, Ohio, on December 13, 1932, Andy, a 62-year-old male, joined the U.S. Air Force at 19 and rose to the rank of Lieutenant Colonel. He served as an F-4 combat fighter pilot during the Vietnam War before retiring. He later earned both a bachelor's degree and an M.B.A. from the University of Washington. On October 10, 1953, he married his hometown sweetheart, Anita Carskadon. For over four decades, they built a life together, raising four children and doting on their seven grandchildren.
They were a hardworking pair who hadn't yet considered retirement, splitting their time between managing a 55-acre RV park in Texas during the fall and winter, and running their commercial real estate business, Pacific Realty, in Washington during the spring and summer.
Anita Anderson, 60, was the heart of the family. Born in Columbus, Ohio, on March 12, 1935, she was a devoted partner in both life and business. She handled the bookkeeping for their real estate firm and served as the Vice President of Finance for their Texas mobile home park. Despite her busy schedule, she always prioritized her children and grandchildren. The couple had lived in the Puyallup, Washington, area for 22 years, having moved there to be close to their growing family. Their two-story brick home was in the upscale Manorwood West subdivision, a quiet neighborhood that had once been showcased in a "Street of Dreams" home show.
The evening of Tuesday, May 16, 1995, was a typical one for the devoted grandparents. They were last seen alive around 8:30 p.m., attending a spring concert for their grandchildren at the Cascade Christian School in downtown Puyallup. They left the concert, presumably to head home for the night. The next day, May 17, calls to the Anderson home went unanswered. Concerned, their daughter and son-in-law went to check on them that evening. At approximately 8:40 p.m., they entered the house in the 3700 block of 21st Street Southeast and made a devastating discovery. Andy and Anita were sitting together on the family room couch, both deceased.
Both Andy and Anita had been shot multiple times, including execution-style wounds to the head. Investigators from the Puyallup Police Department were immediately struck by the perplexing nature of the crime scene. There were no signs of a forced entry, no indication of a struggle, and no property appeared to be missing from the residence. Police believed the couple may have been killed shortly after returning from the concert the previous night. The lack of disturbance at the scene led detectives to surmise that the murders were not a random act or the result of a botched burglary. They publicly stated their belief that the victims may have known their killer or killers.
The brutal and efficient nature of the slayings led the Pierce County Medical Examiner to suggest the crime resembled a "professional hit." This theory, however, only deepened the mystery, as investigators could find no motive for anyone to target the well-liked and respected couple. The double homicide, the first in Puyallup in at least two decades, sent a wave of fear through the quiet community. More than 300 residents attended a community meeting with police shortly after the murders, seeking answers and reassurance. Police increased patrols but could only tell the anxious public that they believed it was an isolated incident.
Decades have passed, but the murders of Graig and Anita Anderson remain unsolved. Their four children and seven grandchildren were left to mourn and wonder who could have committed such a senseless act of violence. Services for the couple were held on May 23, 1995, at the Puyallup Church of the Nazarene. The case is still an active cold case with the Puyallup Police Department, which continues to ask for the public's help.
As of a May 2025 report, investigators are still seeking information about any suspicious people or vehicles that may have been seen near the Anderson's home on the night of May 16 or the day of May 17, 1995. A significant reward is available for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible. Anyone with information is urged to call the Puyallup Police Department tip line at 253-841-5427 or Tacoma-Pierce County Crime Stoppers at 253-591-5959. Callers can remain anonymous.