It was a cold Tuesday in December when the body of a young woman was found. On December 13, 1994, authorities were called to a junkyard on A Street in the industrial district of Johnston, Rhode Island, where they made the grim discovery. The woman was identified as Evelyn Sanchez, a resident of nearby Providence who was also known to some as "Candy." She had been reported missing from Providence approximately one week before her body was found.
Investigators from the Johnston Police Department quickly determined that Evelyn’s death was a homicide. The circumstances of her discovery led detectives to believe that the junkyard was not the primary crime scene. Evidence suggested that she had been killed at a different location and her body was later brought to the secluded industrial area and left face down.
The exact cause of her death has not been publicly released by investigators, who have only classified it as a homicide.
The investigation into who killed Evelyn Sanchez has now spanned decades, passing through the hands of multiple generations of detectives. In the initial stages, police worked to piece together a timeline of her last known movements, focusing on the week between her disappearance in Providence and the discovery of her body in Johnston. They sought information from family, friends, and the public, hoping for a lead that would point them toward a suspect or explain what happened to the young woman in her final days.
Despite their efforts, the case grew cold. No suspects were publicly named, and no arrests were ever made. The trail of evidence, once warm, faded with the passage of time. Yet, investigators in Johnston have refused to let Evelyn's case be forgotten. In an effort to generate new leads from the public, her homicide was included in a special deck of cold case playing cards distributed throughout the state's correctional facilities. Each card featured a photograph and details of an unsolved homicide or missing person case, with the hope that an inmate might have information and be compelled to come forward.
Years later, the commitment to solving the crime remains. In September 2019, nearly 25 years after Evelyn’s death, Johnston police detectives affirmed that the investigation was still an active and open cold case. They emphasized that the case "isn't going away" and that they remained hopeful that someone, somewhere holds the key piece of information that could finally bring resolution. The original detective who worked the crime scene expressed his hope that a person's conscience might lead them to come forward after so many years.
As of the fall of 2019, the case of who murdered Evelyn Sanchez remains unsolved, a lingering question for her family and the Johnston community. The Johnston Police Department continues to seek information from the public. Anyone with information regarding the disappearance or death of Evelyn Sanchez is encouraged to contact the Johnston Police Department at (401) 231-4210.