Sean Goggin was just 20 years old and beginning a new life in America when he was senselessly killed. A native of Youghal, a seaside resort town in County Cork, Ireland, Sean was a skilled pattern maker. He had spent two years in Canada before making his way to Worcester, Massachusetts, arriving only about a week before his death. He was poised to start a new job the very next day. In Worcester, Sean, a male, moved into the home of Cornelius Herlihy and his wife at 191 Fairhaven Road in the city's Burncoat neighborhood. Herlihy was the uncle of one of Sean's schoolmates from back in Ireland.
The night of Sunday, March 11, 1951, was dark and rainy. At around 10:30 p.m., an odd phone call came to the Herlihy house. The caller, identifying himself as "Mr. Anderson," told Cornelius Herlihy he would be able to "pay him tomorrow." Herlihy, who didn't know anyone by that name, was puzzled by the call.
Just 15 minutes later, as the household was preparing for bed, there was a knock on the back door. Two men, dressed in trench coats, claimed to be from Western Union with a telegram. When Sean Goggin opened the door, the visitors revealed their true intent.
At least one of the men was masked, wearing a handkerchief over his face, and brandished a handgun, announcing, "This is a holdup." As Cornelius Herlihy bravely grabbed for the weapon, a struggle ensued, and a shot was fired into the ceiling. The second intruder, armed with a.32-caliber Colt, then fired two more shots. One of the bullets struck Sean directly in the heart. He collapsed in the entryway and died within 15 minutes. The two assailants fled across the lawn, jumped into what witnesses described as a small, four-door black sedan, and sped away into the night.
The Worcester Police Department launched an extensive investigation into the shocking murder of the young immigrant. Investigators at the time theorized that the crime was a botched robbery or kidnapping attempt. They speculated that the intended target was Cornelius Herlihy, who was the sales manager for United Dairy System Inc. The assailants may have planned to force him to open the company's safe. One of the few pieces of evidence left at the scene was a brown, size-seven felt hat from the Merrimac Hat Co., dropped by one of the suspects. Despite what modern investigators have called a thorough and impressive initial inquiry, the murder weapon was never found, and the case grew cold.
In the weeks following the murder, Sean’s grieving parents, John and Madge Goggin, wrote to Worcester Police Chief William P. Finneran from Ireland. They expressed their deep sorrow and distress over misleading newspaper reports, emphasizing their son's innocence. "We are greatly grieved by the murder of our son in such tragic circumstances," they wrote, adding that their son had no connection to the gunmen. Chief Finneran wrote back, assuring them that the "investigation discloses that your son was not involved with any gangster movement in this city, and from all appearances was an innocent victim of circumstances." He promised the family that police were making every effort to find the men "responsible for this most dastardly act." Sean's body was flown back to Ireland for burial near his family home.
Decades passed, but the case was never closed. In August 2012, the Worcester Police Department's Unresolved Homicide Unit announced a new development. Investigators had located evidence from the original case file that they believed was suitable for modern DNA testing. "We've recently located some evidence that we believe is of probative value to us," Detective Sergeant Mark J. Sawyer said at the time, expressing hope that a DNA profile could be developed at the state crime lab. Police acknowledged that while the perpetrators might no longer be alive, scientific evidence could finally bring a resolution to the long-unanswered questions.
As of May 2023 and with updates in April 2024, the murder of Sean Goggin remains the oldest unsolved homicide on the books for the Worcester Police Department. The DNA testing results have not led to any public updates or arrests. The promise made to Sean's parents more than seventy years ago has yet to be fulfilled, and the identity of the two men who knocked on the door of 191 Fairhaven Road on that rainy March night remains a mystery.