Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
The last time Dominick Maiorana saw his son, Paul Maiorana, was the day after Christmas in 1999. In the weeks that followed, Dominick wasn't immediately worried. He later told police it wasn't unusual for his 21-year-old son to be out of touch for extended periods. But as January wore on, a series of events would unfold that revealed Paul had not just been out of touch, but had met a violent and tragic end. Paul was a young White / Caucasian man from the Worcester suburb of Auburn, Massachusetts, known by neighbors for his mint-condition silver 1999 Lexus CS300, a car he was often seen working on, installing speakers in the trunk.

For weeks, the distinctive Lexus sat parked and unmoved on Eastern Avenue in Worcester. On January 19, 2000, police had the vehicle towed to Pat's Service Center on Shrewsbury Street. Six days later, on January 25, the Worcester Police Department's records bureau contacted Dominick Maiorana to inform him that his car was at the tow yard. Alarmed, having not seen his son for a month, Dominick immediately called the Auburn Police Department to officially report Paul missing.

Later that same day, an Auburn police officer investigating the new missing person report went to Pat's Service Center to inspect the Lexus. The officer opened the trunk and made a devastating discovery. Inside was the body of Paul Maiorana. He had been shot once in the head. According to reports from a local true-crime podcast, "Unsolved: Worcester," which covered the case, Paul's body was frozen, a grim testament to the bitter cold of that January and the length of time he had been missing.

The investigation into the homicide of Paul Maiorana was launched by the Worcester Police Department. The timeline was difficult to establish precisely because of how long he had been missing and the condition of his body. He was last seen alive on December 26, 1999, and his car had been left on Eastern Avenue for at least two weeks before being towed. Investigators were left with many unanswered questions: Where was Paul killed? Who drove his car to Eastern Avenue and abandoned it? No neighbors in the area reported hearing a gunshot, and it did not appear that Paul had been robbed.

As detectives delved into Paul's life, they uncovered potential sources of conflict. Just two months before his death, on November 3, 1999, Paul was one of three suspects arrested for an armed home invasion in Maine. During the robbery of a 17-year-old, thousands of dollars in jewelry and cash were stolen. Paul was reportedly the only one of the robbers who did not wear a mask, and the victim, who knew him, easily identified him to police. Police also learned that Paul and the victim of the robbery were both allegedly involved in drug dealing. While investigators explored possible connections between the home invasion and Paul's murder, they were unable to publicly link the two events.

Decades have passed, but the murder of Paul Maiorana has never been solved. His case was featured in "Unsolved: Worcester," a podcast and video series that explores the city's cold cases, in an episode titled "Found Frozen in the Trunk" released in November 2022 and updated in April 2024. The series aims to bring fresh attention to cases like Paul's in the hope that someone, somewhere, will come forward with the missing piece of the puzzle.

The case remains an active investigation with the Worcester Police Department's Unresolved Homicide Unit. Investigators believe that after more than two decades, relationships and loyalties may have changed, and someone with knowledge of the crime might now be willing to speak. Anyone with information about the murder of Paul Maiorana is urged to contact the Unresolved Homicide Unit at 508-799-8688. Anonymous tips can also be sent by texting TIPWPD and your message to 274637, or submitted via the department's website.