Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
In the waning days of autumn 1998, a grim discovery was made along the banks of the Puyallup River in Washington state, beginning a mystery that has now spanned decades. James Foglesong, a 74-year-old male resident of nearby Puyallup, was found deceased on the afternoon of Monday, December 7, 1998. A person passing by spotted his body on the riverbank in the 17900 block of Leach Road, just to the east of the city of Sumner, and alerted authorities. The serene landscape of the river valley had become a crime scene.

An autopsy revealed that James Foglesong had not died of natural causes or an accident. He had been shot multiple times. Investigators from the Pierce County Sheriff's Department determined that the riverbank was not where the murder occurred. Foglesong had been killed at an unknown, secondary location, and his body was later transported and abandoned alongside the Puyallup River. This deliberate act to conceal the crime added a layer of complexity for detectives trying to piece together his final moments.

The investigation into Foglesong's life and activities uncovered a crucial detail that may have led to his death. Detectives learned that he was involved in growing marijuana at his residence in Puyallup. This discovery opened a primary avenue of investigation, with authorities believing his murder could have been connected to his involvement in the drug trade. Robbery or a dispute related to this activity were considered strong potential motives for such a violent crime against an elderly man.

A significant challenge for investigators was establishing a timeline of Foglesong's final days. He was last seen alive approximately three days before his body was found, leaving a critical gap of time unaccounted for. His whereabouts and activities during this period remain unknown, a black hole in an investigation that has grown cold over the years. Who he met with and where he went during those last 72 hours are questions that investigators have tirelessly sought to answer, believing the key to identifying his killer lies within that missing time.

The Pierce County Sheriff's Department has kept the case open, hoping for a break that will lead them to the person or persons responsible for the murder of James Foglesong. Over the years, details of the case have been shared publicly through media outlets and cold case listings, including a roundup of unsolved cases by KIRO 7 news in May 2025. These efforts aim to jog the memory of anyone who might have seen something or someone suspicious in early December 1998, either near Foglesong's home or the location where his body was left.

More than two decades later, the murder of James Foglesong remains an unsolved homicide. The passage of time has not diminished the need for answers or the pursuit of justice. Detectives continue to ask for the public's help, believing that someone holds the missing piece of information that could finally bring closure to the case. Tacoma/Pierce County Crime Stoppers is still seeking tips from anyone who may know the identity of the suspect or suspects responsible for this brutal crime.