Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
To his family in the Bronx, New York, Robert Natiello Jr. was a good person, a young man who worked hard at a local bakery and always went out of his way to help those he loved. His mother, Camille Natiello, remembers him as a family-oriented son. But she also saw another side to him, a life that pulled him toward danger. She tried to warn him about the people he was with, but he would just tell her not to worry. Robert was 25 years old, a male with his whole life ahead of him, but he was seduced by the fast life, a life that would ultimately cost him everything.

Robert’s sister, Lori Ann Beca, recalled her last, pleading conversation with her brother. "I said, what are you doing?" she remembered telling him. "I don't want to bury my brother. If something happens to you, Mom and Dad will be devastated." Robert’s response was tragically dismissive: "Don't jinx me." His family's love for him was immense, and their inability to pull him away from the path he had chosen is a source of pain that has not faded with time. In the world he straddled outside his family home, Robert was known by his street name, "White Boy."

On the night of January 20, 2003, that world caught up to him in a back alley off Washington Street in Haverhill, Massachusetts, about 35 miles north of Boston. Investigators believe Robert had driven two associates from the Bronx to Haverhill to collect a significant drug debt, reported to be around $90,000 for a shipment of marijuana. Robert’s role, they believe, was simply to provide transportation because he had a car; he was not considered the ringleader of the operation. As the group left a building and walked through the alley toward Robert’s car, someone stepped up to him, pointed a gun at his forehead, and fired a single shot just over his left eye.

Robert Natiello Jr. collapsed in the alley and never regained consciousness. He was rushed to a hospital, where he succumbed to his catastrophic injury two days later, on January 22, 2003. The brazen and personal nature of the shooting has always stood out to investigators. "When you're shot over your left eye, that's personal, face to face," Essex County District Attorney Jonathan Blodgett stated. "We don't believe it was mistaken identity or a stray bullet. We believe all the parties knew each other." Why Robert was the one targeted, and not the person who was there to collect the debt, remains one of the case's most perplexing questions.

The investigation into Robert’s murder was launched by the Haverhill Police Department and the Massachusetts State Police assigned to the Essex County District Attorney's office. Detectives believe there were multiple witnesses in the alley that night, people who saw exactly what happened. Yet, years have passed without an arrest. The wall of silence has been a source of deep frustration for Robert’s family. "We just can't believe there were so many people there that witnessed this, and nobody has the goodness to say anything," his sister, Carmella Pervizi, said in an interview. "It's unbelievable, after all this time."

For Robert’s mother, Camille, the passage of time has not diminished her hope for justice. She has never walked away from her son, not in life and not in death. Her desire to confront the person who took her son’s life is a powerful motivator. "I hope to God I'll be able to get up (in court) and face that person that killed my son!" she has said. The family’s grief is compounded by the knowledge that the killer has been free for more than two decades.

As of May 2019, Robert Natiello Jr.'s murder remains an active, unsolved case. Investigators continue to believe that someone in the community has the information needed to finally bring the killer to justice. They urge anyone who knows anything about the murder of the man known as "White Boy" to come forward. The Massachusetts State Police assigned to the Essex County District Attorney's office are asking for tips at 978-745-8908.