Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 5 sources
Christopher Schmeller was a 31-year-old fisherman from Westerly, Rhode Island, who lived a somewhat transient life, often staying with friends. He was known to have an extensive criminal history dating back to 1989, with arrests for offenses that included assault, reckless driving, and carrying a pistol without a license. Despite his troubles, friends cared for him, and when he vanished, they were the ones who raised the alarm, posting his picture throughout Westerly in the hopes of finding him.

The last time friends saw Christopher was on September 26, 2002, at a court appearance in Westerly. They later told police that he was uncharacteristically nervous that day. His anxiety was reportedly caused by the presence of a man he feared who had shown up at the courthouse. Friends grew concerned when they couldn't reach him, and on September 30, 2002, they officially reported him missing to the police. Their search for answers came to a devastating end just over a week later.

On the morning of October 8, 2002, utility workers discovered a body about 10 feet down a sloped embankment in a wooded area off Parkway South in Waterford, Connecticut. The location was on the property of the former Waterford Airport. The remains were badly decomposed, indicating they had been exposed to the elements for some time before being found. An autopsy identified the man as Christopher Schmeller and determined that he had died from blunt force trauma to the head. His death was immediately classified as a homicide.

The Waterford Police Department took the lead on the investigation, working with law enforcement in Rhode Island. The condition of Christopher’s body made it difficult for investigators to collect DNA evidence from the scene. The location where he was found was also grimly familiar to local police; it was the third body discovered on the old airport property in five years. In 1997, the body of Renee Pellegrino was found there, a murder for which Dickie Anderson was later convicted. And in April 2002, just months before Christopher’s discovery, the decomposed remains of Philip Scaplen were also found on the property; his death was never officially determined. Investigators have not publicly stated if they believe Christopher's murder is connected to any other cases.

Over the years, the investigation into Christopher’s murder grew cold. In December 2012, a decade after his death, the Waterford Police Department made a public appeal for new information, hoping to "warm up" their only unsolved homicide case. Detective Sgt. Joe DePasquale noted that over time, loyalties can break, and people who were once silent might be willing to come forward. Friends of Christopher told reporters they believed his murder may have stemmed from a drug or gun-related vendetta.

To keep the case in the public eye, Christopher Schmeller's homicide was included in the third edition of Connecticut's cold case playing cards, which are distributed to inmates in the state's correctional facilities. His case was featured as the queen of diamonds in the deck released in October 2014. The program has been successful in generating tips and leading to arrests in other unsolved cases across the state.

As of the last public updates, Christopher Schmeller's murder remains unsolved. The Waterford Police Department continues to seek information from anyone who might know what happened to him in the fall of 2002. Anyone with information is urged to contact the Waterford Police Department's detective division at (860) 442-9451 or the Westerly, Rhode Island Police Department at (401) 596-2022.