Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 9 sources
Wendy Madden had a tough life, but she was loved. Her brother, John Madden, remembers the sister who was taken from him just five days after her 23rd birthday in March 1991. He wonders what her life might have been like if she had been given the chance to turn things around, to get married, have children, or go to college. Instead, her memory is preserved in family photos and on the nine of hearts in a deck of cold case playing cards distributed by Rhode Island law enforcement, a constant, quiet plea for justice.

On the cold Monday night of March 11, 1991, Wendy left the Pawtucket, Rhode Island home she shared with her mother at around 11:00 p.m. She was just walking a few minutes to a nearby convenience store, Store 24, to buy a pack of cigarettes. She made it to the store and was reportedly seen afterward near the intersection of Railroad Street and Cross Street, not far from her house, talking with people. But after that, the trail went cold. Wendy Madden never made it home.

Two days later, on March 13, a neighbor who lived next to a local bar called Jan's Place on Middle Street was taking out her trash when she made a horrifying discovery. Behind the building lay the body of a young woman. It was Wendy. An autopsy would later reveal the brutal nature of her death: she had been raped and strangled. The bar, which Wendy sometimes visited, was only an eight- to ten-minute walk from her home. It has since been demolished, leaving only a grassy lot where a young woman’s life came to a violent end.

The Pawtucket Police Department launched a homicide investigation, but the case grew cold over the years. Hope for a resolution was reignited in 2013 when Detective Sue Cormier, who had joined the force two years after the murder, officially reopened the investigation. The break came from an unexpected tip passed on by an investigator from another department. That tip led Cormier to pull five boxes of evidence from storage. The original case files were handwritten, and the crime scene photos were missing. In a stroke of luck and persistence, Cormier found the misfiled photographic negatives in the City Hall archives and had them developed.

Cormier immersed herself in the decades-old files, a process she likened to reading a novel over and over. "There’s a saying with cold cases that your suspect is somewhere in the original case files," Cormier once stated. "It’s rare it’s not there as a witness." The investigation benefited from modern technology unavailable in 1991. Evidence was submitted for advanced DNA testing, and old VHS tapes from the case were digitized. Cormier tracked down and re-interviewed original witnesses, traveling to other states to follow leads in her meticulous effort to piece together Wendy's last hours.

For Wendy’s family, the decades without answers have been agonizing. Her brother, John, has remained in contact with detectives, holding out hope for a conviction. He described his sister's killer as a "coward," stating, "No one should take anyone's life." He has expressed a wish for a memorial to be placed at the corner of Middle Street, a way to ensure his sister is never forgotten while he waits for justice.

As of August 2022, Wendy Madden's murder remains an active but unsolved cold case. No arrests have been made, and no one has been convicted for her death. Detective Cormier, who keeps a picture of Wendy on her desk, has been a dedicated advocate for the victims in her care, using social media and news outlets to keep their stories alive. The investigation into who killed Wendy Madden continues. Anyone with information is encouraged to call 1-877-RI-SOLVE.