Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 1 source
An autumn evening in 1974 brought shocking violence to a quiet residential street in Boston’s Dorchester neighborhood, leaving three people dead and a mystery that has endured for decades. The city at that time was a landscape of tension, embroiled in the social and political turmoil of court-ordered school busing that had begun just a month earlier. But for the residents of the multi-family home at 170 Bowdoin Street, the conflict that arrived at their door on Wednesday, October 2, 1974, was of a much more personal and brutal nature.

That evening, Boston Police officers were dispatched to Apartment 2 at the Bowdoin Street address following a report of a person shot. Inside the apartment, they discovered a scene of carnage. Three people had been killed by gunfire. They were identified as 68-year-old Elizabeth Hardiman, 61-year-old Dorothy Boughman, and 23-year-old Glen Boughman. All three were pronounced deceased at the scene. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner would later officially rule their deaths as homicides.

The sparse details released at the time have left a void where the stories of Elizabeth, Dorothy, and Glen should be. Public records offer no insight into their lives, their occupations, or their family connections. It is not publicly known what relationship Elizabeth Hardiman had to Dorothy and Glen Boughman, or why they were all together in the second-floor apartment of the brick building that day. Whether they were family, friends, or simply neighbors caught in a tragic moment remains one of the case's unanswered questions. The motive behind the triple homicide has also never been determined or released by investigators.

The investigation into the triple murder was launched by the Boston Police Department's Homicide Unit. In 1974, the city was grappling with a significant number of homicides, and detectives were stretched thin. The social fabric of Boston was frayed, particularly in neighborhoods like Dorchester, as communities reacted to the forced desegregation of public schools. This volatile city-wide atmosphere formed a challenging backdrop for any homicide investigation, demanding immense resources and attention from law enforcement.

Despite the initial investigation and the passage of more than fifty years, no arrests have ever been made in the murders of Elizabeth Hardiman, Dorothy Boughman, and Glen Boughman. The case has grown cold, its files holding questions that have long outlived any immediate answers. There is no public information about any potential suspects or persons of interest that may have been identified over the years. Details about the evidence collected at the scene, if any, have not been shared.

The case of this unsolved triple homicide is now one of the oldest cold cases on the Boston Police Department's records. As of 2024, the murders of Elizabeth, Dorothy, and Glen are listed on the department's webpage for unsolved homicides from 1974, a silent testament to a crime that has never seen justice. The families and friends of the victims have waited half a century for a resolution that has never come.

The Boston Police Department continues to seek information that could finally shed light on this horrific crime. They urge anyone with knowledge about the murders of Elizabeth Hardiman, Dorothy Boughman, and Glen Boughman to come forward. The Homicide Unit can be reached at (617) 343-4470. For those who wish to remain anonymous, tips can be provided through the Crime Stoppers Tip Line at 1 (800) 494-TIPS.

Links to Additional Sources (1)

See any mistakes? Let us know!