In the pre-dawn hours of Friday, March 1, 1963, the life of 32-year-old James Smith, a male resident of Boston's Roxbury neighborhood, came to a sudden and violent end. For more than six decades, the question of who shot him and why has echoed through the city, leaving his case as a stark reminder of a life cut short and a crime unsolved. Today, it stands as the oldest cold case actively publicized by the Boston Police Department, a silent testament to a search for justice that has spanned generations.
The fatal encounter took place inside Smith's apartment at 29 Wyoming Street. At approximately 2:45 a.m., Smith was at home with two female friends, aged 21 and 22. The two women were chatting in the kitchen, away from Smith, when the night was shattered by the sound of gunfire. Witnesses reported hearing four distinct shots ring out within the apartment. In the immediate aftermath, a man described only as a stranger was seen running out through the kitchen.
He fled into the night, getting into a car that was parked nearby before speeding away from the scene.
When police and first responders arrived, they found James Smith mortally wounded. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner would later determine his cause of death was homicide by gunshot. A notable detail reported at the time and reiterated by police in modern appeals was that Smith was found wearing women's clothing when he was killed. This fact, while recorded, has never been publicly explained in the context of the crime, leaving another unanswered question for investigators.
The Boston Police Department has been investigating the homicide since that night in 1963. In the initial stages, they spoke with the two women who were present in the apartment and other potential witnesses. However, the trail of the unidentified man who fled the scene quickly went cold. Over the decades, the case has remained open, passed down through generations of detectives. Despite the passage of time, no arrests have ever been made, and no suspects have been publicly named.
In a renewed effort to generate leads on hundreds of unsolved murders, the Boston Police Department in recent years created a web page dedicated to its cold cases, with James Smith's 1963 murder being the oldest one featured. Sergeant Detective Nick Moore of the homicide unit stated that the goal is to ensure victims are not forgotten and to seek information that people may have withheld for years. "There’s always something that somebody’s been withholding over the years," Moore said. He expressed hope that with the passage of time, people who were once afraid to speak may have a change of heart or wish to clear their conscience.
As of October 2025, the investigation into the murder of James Smith remains open. Detectives believe that even after more than 60 years, someone, somewhere, holds the key to understanding what happened in that Roxbury apartment. The department emphasizes that even a small, seemingly insignificant detail could be the missing piece that finally allows them to move forward. Police hope that by keeping the case in the public eye, they can bring a measure of closure and long-awaited justice for a man whose life was stolen on a cold winter night.
The Boston Police Department urges anyone with information about the homicide of James Smith to contact the Homicide Unit at 617-343-4470. For those who wish to remain anonymous, tips can be submitted by calling the Crime Stoppers Hotline at 1-800-494-TIPS.