Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 2 sources
The summer of 2002 was unfolding in Boston when the life of a young man, Timothy Mathis, was cut short by sudden violence. A Black / African American man of 26, his story is now preserved in the public record primarily through the tragic details of his death, leaving behind unanswered questions that have lingered for more than two decades. Who he was—his dreams, his passions, the family and friends who held him dear—remains held in the private memories of those who knew him, absent from the public chronicle of his unsolved case.

On the evening of Thursday, August 1, 2002, the sound of gunfire shattered the quiet on Vaughan Avenue in the city’s Dorchester neighborhood. When officers from the Boston Police Department arrived at number 22, they found Timothy Mathis suffering from gunshot wounds. According to one memorial registry, he had been shot in the head. He was pronounced deceased at the scene. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner later conducted an autopsy and officially ruled the manner of death a homicide, confirming that Timothy had been killed by the intentional act of another.

The investigation into Timothy’s murder was launched immediately by the Boston Police Department’s Homicide Unit. In 2002, Boston was experiencing a significant number of homicides, and detectives in the unit were tasked with navigating a landscape of complex and often violent crimes across the city. Dorchester, Boston's largest and one of its most diverse neighborhoods, was no stranger to such tragedies. The area around Vaughan Avenue, just off Geneva Avenue and near the Four Corners/Geneva commuter rail station, is a dense residential community. In that era, while crime rates in Boston had seen a decrease from the highs of the early 1990s, gun violence remained a persistent threat.

Detectives would have canvassed the neighborhood, a collection of multi-family homes and apartment buildings, searching for witnesses who saw or heard something that night. They would have meticulously processed the crime scene, collecting forensic evidence and looking for any clue that could point to a suspect or a motive. Despite these efforts, the investigation stalled. No suspects were publicly identified, no arrests were made, and the specific circumstances that led to Timothy’s death have never been officially released. The case grew cold, one of many that year to remain without resolution.

Over the years, the file on Timothy Mathis has remained open. The Boston Police Department maintains a roster of unsolved homicides on its website, a quiet digital memorial and a standing appeal for information. Timothy’s name is listed there among dozens of others from 2002, a stark reminder of a life taken and a case yet to be closed. The department’s Unsolved/Cold Case Squad is tasked with reviewing such cases, hoping that new technology, a fresh look at the evidence, or a witness finally coming forward could provide the breakthrough needed for an arrest.

As of today, more than twenty years after his death, no charges have been filed in the murder of Timothy Mathis. The case remains an open and active investigation in the files of the Boston Police Department. For his family and friends, the years have passed without answers or justice. The silence surrounding his death is a heavy one, leaving only the official record of a young life ended by gunfire on a summer night in Dorchester.

The Boston Police Department continues to ask for the public’s help in solving this and other cold cases. Anyone with information regarding the homicide of Timothy Mathis is urged to contact the BPD Homicide Unit at 617-343-4470. For those who wish to remain anonymous, tips can be submitted through the Crime Stoppers Text-A-Tip Program or by calling the Crime Stoppers Hotline at 1-800-494-TIPS.

Links to Additional Sources (2)

See any mistakes? Let us know!