Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
Susan Dequina was a vibrant, 22-year-old single mother who was fiercely protective of her loved ones, especially her younger sister, Brenda, who lived with muscular dystrophy. Her family remembered her as a rebellious spirit who grew up fast, a fan of Jimi Hendrix who embraced the 1960s ideals of peace and love. By the fall of 1979, Susan was living in an apartment in Lynn, Massachusetts, with her two young sons, Roland and Adam. Her life, however, had become entangled with a dangerous crowd, a connection that police believe led to her disappearance and presumed death.

On the evening of October 3, 1979, Susan hired a teenage neighbor to babysit her sons. She explained that her boyfriend, Michele Gagnon, was taking her to buy a new refrigerator. Gagnon was an alleged member of the Quebec chapter of the Hells Angels motorcycle club and sometimes stayed at her apartment. When the babysitter arrived, the apartment was filled with people who all left with Susan and Gagnon around 6:00 p.m. It was the last time her children saw her. The babysitter waited through the night, but Susan never came back. Around 1:00 a.m., Gagnon returned to the apartment alone. The next day, Susan’s concerned parents reported her missing.

The investigation into Susan’s disappearance quickly uncovered a series of violent and interconnected events. Shortly after she vanished, her car was found burned near the Saugus town line. Investigators developed a theory that Susan may have wanted to end her relationship with Gagnon. It was believed that he and his Hells Angels associates were using her credit cards to rent vehicles for trafficking drugs, and she may have threatened to expose them. The case grew darker and more complex on November 4, 1979, when a human torso was discovered near where Susan’s car had been torched. The remains were identified as Robert Garbino, a roommate of Gagnon’s and a member of a local outlaw motorcycle gang. A subsequent search of the house Garbino and Gagnon shared revealed Garbino's severed head and hands. He had been shot to death before being dismembered.

Lynn Police sought to question Michele Gagnon about both Susan’s disappearance and Garbino’s gruesome murder, but they never got the chance. On November 25, 1979, just weeks after the other events, Gagnon himself was found dead from a gunshot wound in an apartment in Bridgeport, Connecticut. While his death was officially listed as a suicide, investigators have remained skeptical, noting that given his background, he did not seem like a candidate to take his own life. With the main person of interest dead, the investigation into what happened to Susan Dequina hit a wall.

Decades have passed, but the questions surrounding that violent autumn in 1979 remain. Susan’s son, Adam Dequina, who was only four years old when his mother vanished, has faint, dream-like memories of her. One vivid memory that haunts him is of his mother chasing Gagnon out of their house with a hammer during a chaotic argument. He has spent his adult life searching for closure. "That’s the thing that kills you: the questions," Adam said in a 2020 interview. "It’s like nothing solid. You can only speculate." He does not believe his mother would have ever willingly abandoned her children.

As of January 2020, the Lynn Police Department confirmed that Susan Dequina’s case is still an active and open investigation. She is presumed to be a victim of homicide, and police believe there are people who have information about her fate, the murder of Robert Garbino, and the death of Michele Gagnon. Captain Mark O’Toole of the Lynn Police noted the inherent danger of Susan's associations. "Simply associating with those individuals, dangerous individuals, those with records of firearms, crimes, assaults, narcotic dealings, traveling in those circles, can certainly be risky for anybody," he stated. For the family left behind, the hope for answers endures. "I'm the last man standing," Adam said. "Hopefully we can get some kind of closure for my family."

Anyone with information about the disappearance of Susan Dequina or the murder of Robert Garbino is urged to contact the Lynn Police Department at 781-595-2000. Tips can also be sent via text by messaging the keyword TIPLYNN to 847411.