On the evening of September 28, 2000, three members of a Georgetown, Indiana family were found shot to death in their garage. Five-year-old Jill Catherine Camm, her seven-year-old brother Bradley Ray Camm, and their 35-year-old mother, Kimberly Starr Renn Camm, were discovered by the children’s father, David Camm, who said he had just returned from playing basketball at a nearby church. Jill was still belted in the back seat of the family’s Ford Bronco with a fatal gunshot wound to the head; Bradley was slumped over in the back seat and their mother was on the garage floor.

Authorities arrested and charged David Camm within days, and the case produced multiple trials over more than a decade. Two of Camm’s convictions were overturned on appeal. DNA from a sweatshirt found at the scene was later linked to convicted felon Charles Boney, and his palm print was found on the family vehicle; Boney was convicted in 2006 and received a lengthy sentence. At a third trial in 2013, David Camm was acquitted after the defense argued Boney acted alone.

What details about that night or the evidence in this case stand out to readers who followed it?