A dispute that began at Murphy’s House of Pain on U.S. 12 ended in gunfire on Sunrise Boulevard in Miller Beach, leaving two men dead on September 7, 2013. Vincent Eugene Bugsy Wainwright-Allen, 31 and a lifelong Gary resident, was pronounced dead at the scene; 18-year-old DaVaughn Pitts was taken to Methodist Hospitals Northlake campus and later died. Four other people were wounded in the outbreak of violence.

The disagreement reportedly involved Wainwright, Pitts and others with a group from the Aetna section of the city. Gary police detained one man for questioning and held two reportedly uncooperative witnesses, and launched an intensive investigation.

Wainwright-Allen was a Wirt High School graduate who worked at the Lake County Juvenile Center and operated a lawn care service. He is survived by a daughter, his parents and several siblings. Does anyone have information about that night or about either victim’s movements earlier on September 7, 2013?