John Sullivan was 49 and working as a pizza delivery driver for Just Pizza when he was killed after a delivery in Indianapolis. On January 18, 2014, he went to a building in the 1800 block of Belmont Avenue to drop off an order. The two men who placed the order, Derek Romano and Jeremiah Roberts, had planned to rob him. Sullivan’s body was found the next morning in the building’s basement, and his vehicle was taken.

Coworkers became alarmed when Sullivan failed to return and customers reported undelivered orders. Investigators tracked Romano and Roberts to Wyoming and arrested them two days after the body was discovered; information from the men’s Facebook pages was used during the inquiry. Both were returned to Indianapolis to face murder and robbery charges.