Berry Dee Williams, 29, was killed the night of August 15, 2014, in Michigan City, Indiana. The dispute began after McSwain accused the men of drawing attention that interfered with illicit activity. McSwain reportedly punched Williams, knocking him unconscious, then Crume shot the incapacitated Williams in the head.

After the killing, Crume and McSwain allegedly tried to eliminate the only eyewitness. The day after the shooting they bailed Deanbra Martin out of La Porte County Jail and told him to kill Mallett; instead Martin worked with police as a confidential informant. Crume and McSwain were arrested in September 2014, tried, convicted on September 15, 2015, and each received a 120-year sentence for murder, attempted murder and conspiracy to commit murder. An appeal was denied in December 2016.

Are there still witnesses, friends, or neighbors from Michigan City who remember that night or saw Williams before August 15, 2014?