Delilah Martinez, 40, was shot in Whiting, Indiana, on the evening of October 27, 2019. Police responded to reports of shots fired on the 1100 block of 115th Street and found Martinez lying in the grass with multiple gunshot wounds; she was unresponsive and was pronounced dead the next day. A bullet hole was also found in her car, which had been parked on the street nearby.
Investigators focused on Martinez’s ex-girlfriend, Lydia Conley, 40, of Chicago. Prosecutors say Conley became enraged after Martinez ended their relationship and started dating a man; Martinez had broken up with Conley about a week or two before the shooting. The day before the killing, Conley allegedly confronted Martinez and her new boyfriend and, during a phone call the boyfriend overheard, threatened Martinez’s life. A co-worker told police Martinez had been shaken by that incident.
A murder warrant for Lydia Conley was issued in June 2020, and she was taken into custody in Chicago by the U.S. Marshal’s Great Lakes Fugitive Task Force. At trial the defense attempted to point to another woman as an alternative suspect, but the court excluded that woman’s past unrelated convictions. In June 2022, a jury found Conley guilty and she was sentenced to 70 years in prison. The conviction was later appealed and remained under review as of the latest dated report.
Did anyone in Whiting or Chicago know Delilah or see her car on or after October 27, 2019?