Stephen Flynn, 57, was working a late shift as a Papa John’s delivery driver in Indianapolis when a March 2023 delivery turned deadly. Dispatched to a vacant house on Priscilla Avenue around 11 p.m., Flynn was shot after arriving. His car was stolen and he was found lying in the street with gunshot wounds; he was taken to a nearby hospital where he later died. Reports say the assailants took the pizza but left a significant amount of cash Flynn had been carrying. The stolen vehicle was later recovered abandoned, and investigators traced the pizza order’s phone number and GPS data from the car as part of their inquiry.

The investigation identified a suspect after security footage from a nearby school and an assisted living facility showed a man carrying pizza boxes, and a firearm connected to the shooting was located and linked through DNA. The loss devastated a husband and father of two who had taken the job to enjoy making people happy by bringing them a pizza. Does anyone have information about deliveries or suspicious activity on Priscilla Avenue the night of that March Thursday?