Olivia Rose Huggler was 18 when she was fatally shot after a December 14, 2021 attack at her home on Kirkwood Drive in Evansville, Indiana. She and two brothers were unloading groceries in the garage when a gunman opened fire. Olivia was taken to Deaconess Midtown Hospital and died of her wounds on December 15, 2021; her death was ruled a homicide.

Investigators identified two suspects: Olivia’s older brother, Samuel Huggler, and his friend, Daniel Alvey. Authorities alleged Samuel hired Alvey to attack one of his siblings. Alvey was arrested and charged with murder and attempted murder; Samuel was arrested on charges of inducing attempted murder and conspiracy. Alvey later accepted a plea deal in 2023. Charges against Samuel were dismissed when Alvey declined to testify, then refiled in 2023; Samuel fled, was located in Spain and returned to Vanderburgh County in April 2025 to face murder and attempted murder charges.

Olivia was remembered for her angelic voice and love of playing guitar. Does anyone who knew Olivia or was in that neighborhood in December 2021 have information that could help clarify what happened?