Jeffrey Anderson was 22 and working at a Subway sandwich shop in Portsmouth, Virginia, on October 26, 1992, when he was fatally shot during what police described as a robbery. Jeffrey complied with the robber’s demands, got on the ground and opened the cash register, but was shot in the back after he smiled at the attacker.

Jeffrey’s wife, Letitia, was out buying a wedding band as a surprise and arrived at the shop shortly after the shooting. She was met by police and told her husband was dead. Officers apprehended Joseph soon after the murder. At his trial he continued to deny guilt, reportedly showed no remorse in court and made a remark to Letitia that she took as callous. A judge later imposed the death penalty.

Did anyone remember seeing Jeffrey or the Subway that morning, or have information about the robbery that could shed more light on what happened?