Richard Rosenbluth and his 35-year-old wife Rebecca were found shot to death in their Chesterfield County, Virginia home. Both victims suffered multiple gunshot wounds to the head and neck; Richard was shot twice in the head and Rebecca sustained four gunshot wounds to her head and neck. Investigators treated the deaths as a double homicide tied to a drug-related dispute.

Detectives identified two suspects: 22-year-old Mark Arlo Sheppard, who was known to the Rosenbluths as a cocaine dealer, and Andre Graham. Authorities say Rosenbluth owed Sheppard money, and that motive led to the arrests. Sheppard was apprehended while allegedly attempting to set fire to Richard Rosenbluth’s vehicle.

Both men were charged with capital murder, robbery, and using a firearm in the commission of a felony; Sheppard’s trial resulted in a conviction and a death sentence, while Graham received a life term.