Joe Ray Rumfelt, 71, was found dead in the living room of his Donovan Street home in Selma, Virginia, on December 3, 2013. A relative who could not reach him asked a neighbor to check on him, and the subsequent autopsy showed he died from a combination of gunshot wounds and blunt force trauma to the head. Rumfelt was a United States Army veteran and a retired supervisor for Dominion Virginia Power who enjoyed woodworking and was described as a loving family man.

Investigators concluded the killing stemmed from a robbery plot. Two young men who had recently sold antiques to Rumfelt — 22-year-old Casey Shane Gillispie and 21-year-old Dustin Thomas McClear — learned he kept cash at home and decided to rob him after abandoning a plan to target a Pizza Hut. They allegedly went to his house pretending to sell a BB-gun; Gillispie reportedly produced a .22-caliber revolver, Rumfelt was shot after resisting, McClear later admitted to shooting him multiple times, and Gillispie struck him with a dumbbell. The suspects left with stolen guns and attempted to dispose of the weapons; both weapons were later recovered.

Alleghany County deputies arrested McClear on December 7 and Gillispie on December 9; both were charged and held without bond. McClear pleaded guilty to capital murder and robbery and received two life sentences, one without parole. Does anyone from Selma remember Rumfelt or have information about that December 2013 timeframe?