David Overton Agurs, 27, was shot and killed on May 14, 2015, in a cul-de-sac on Art Avenue in Henrico, Virginia. First responders found him with a gunshot wound, and he was pronounced dead at the scene.

Within weeks Henrico Police identified and arrested two suspects: James Henshaw, then 20, and Tiquez Timmons, then 19. A Henrico County grand jury returned indictments charging both men in connection with Agurs’s homicide. The prosecution alleged the two were responsible for the fatal shooting; the case moved through court and addressed the circumstances of that May afternoon.

Both Henshaw and Timmons were later convicted and received lengthy prison terms. Few public reports have detailed a motive for the killing. Did anyone in the Henrico area see activity on Art Avenue around May 14, 2015, or have information about Agurs’s movements that day?