Thomas J. Nightengale was 41 when he was last seen in West Seneca, New York, on November 27, 1989. He was described as having brown hair, blue eyes, and a scar on his left wrist. At the time he stood five feet eleven inches and weighed about 145 pounds.

Investigation details are sparse. The most significant clue was the recovery of his car near Niagara Falls, a location that raised troubling questions given the powerful waters there. Beyond that discovery, no further evidence or witnesses are reported, and the case file is listed as NamUs MP70657.

Anyone who knew Thomas, his movements in late November 1989, or who might have seen the car near Niagara Falls is asked to come forward with information.