On the night of December 15–16, 2021, Andre Willie Garner, 27, of Muskegon was shot multiple times after a fight at the MI Bar in Norton Shores and died at the scene despite attempts to save him. Bar security cameras captured the incident and several witnesses were present.

Authorities identified 40-year-old Kyle Robbins as the suspect. Witnesses said Robbins and Garner knew one another. Robbins fled after the shooting and surrendered to police at a park-and-ride lot on December 21, 2021. He was charged with open murder, carrying a concealed weapon, being a felon in possession of a firearm, two counts of felony firearm, and charged as a habitual offender; a $2 million bond was set. Defense counsel argued the shooting was self-defense and described Garner as a very large man who allegedly attacked Robbins from behind. Police asked for additional witnesses to come forward.

Did anyone at the MI Bar that night or anyone who knew Andre or Kyle come forward with information?