Peggy Lee Gaytan, 55, was working the night shift at a Shell station at 36th Street and Harvard Avenue in Tulsa when she was fatally shot during an armed robbery on December 22, 2011. Surveillance video shows two men running into the convenience store moments before the shot that killed her.

Investigators pursued leads for years, including inquiries that reached into Colorado, and family and friends held vigils to keep her memory alive. In May 2020 police announced an arrest in the case, but that development was later reversed when prosecutors dropped charges in September 2020 after a key witness declined to testify.

The killing remains unsolved. If anyone who worked at or visited that Shell station in December 2011 has information about the two men seen on video, please come forward to help bring Peggy’s family answers.