David D. McKay, 38, was shot near 67th and Stevenson in Milwaukee on June 23, 2016 and died of his wounds the next day. A neighbor first mistook the sounds for fireworks before finding McKay with two gunshot wounds in his back; he was taken to a hospital where he later died.

Investigators say McKay had been at a party that evening. According to the criminal complaint, someone at the party told Garry Stewart that McKay might be carrying a large amount of money. Stewart and an accomplice, Lolita Whitehead, reportedly followed McKay after he left. Stewart attempted to rob McKay and shot him; Whitehead is accused of driving Stewart to and from the scene. Stewart allegedly returned to the car with money visible in his jacket pockets and the pair used stolen cash to buy items and a hotel room.

Stewart was charged with counts including reckless homicide; Whitehead was charged with harboring or aiding a felon. Stewart faced a potential maximum sentence of 60 years for the most serious charge; Whitehead faced up to ten years and a $25,000 fine. Did anyone nearby see McKay leave the party or notice the car Whitehead reportedly drove that night?