On December 6, 2020, Andre Nicholson, a 24-year-old Black man, was shot and killed after an argument inside a Third Ward bar in Milwaukee. The dispute reportedly began over which of two former high schools had the better basketball team; Nicholson was asked to leave and was followed outside by 23-year-old Caesar Fuentes. While on the phone with his uncle arranging a ride, Nicholson was shot multiple times in an alley near Water and Buffalo streets. Family arrived before first responders and attempted aid; an autopsy later found six gunshot wounds.

Fuentes surrendered to police later that day and was charged with first-degree reckless homicide and use of a dangerous weapon. His family turned over a handgun that investigators said was consistent with casings at the scene. Some reports say racial slurs may have been used during the altercation. If anyone has information about the bar confrontation or the moments outside, please share what you know.