On the evening of October 10, 2022, twelve-year-old Olivia Schultz was shot and killed in the alley behind her Milwaukee home near 37th and Rohr while helping her mother, Celeste Wilson, unload groceries. Two masked teenagers approached; after a brief exchange they began to walk away and, from about four houses down, one of the teens turned and opened fire. Wilson was struck in the back and survived; Olivia was fatally wounded and later died at a hospital.

Olivia, remembered as a sweet girl who liked to cook and make TikTok videos and the youngest of six children, became the victim of gun violence that night. Milwaukee police arrested two teenage suspects, 17-year-old Benjamin Garrett and 16-year-old Cornell Henard, charging both as adults. Family members identified Garrett as one of the people in the alley; Henard reportedly told police both he and Garrett fired shots and that Garrett fired first. Garrett later pleaded guilty to first-degree reckless homicide and first-degree reckless endangerment and in June 2023 was sentenced to 22 years in prison.

Did anyone in the neighborhood see the two masked teenagers that night or know anything about their movements before the shooting?