Kenneth Neafus, 71, and his wife Dorothy were found dead in their rural Morgantown, Kentucky home on Richland Church Road on August 9, 2016. Kenneth, a retired pastor who had served at Little Muddy Cumberland Presbyterian Church, and his wife were discovered by a family member. The coroner determined both died of gunshot wounds, and the deaths were ruled a double homicide.

Investigators noted a firearm and prescription medication were missing from the residence and considered robbery a possible motive. Evidence at the scene led detectives to focus on a local man, Kevin Dye. In September 2016 a Butler County grand jury indicted Dye on multiple counts, including two counts of murder, possession of a handgun by a convicted felon, receiving stolen property, and being a persistent felony offender. In December 2018 Dye entered an Alford plea, permitting conviction without an admission of guilt, and the court later imposed life without parole.

If anyone knew Kenneth or Dorothy Neafus, lived nearby, or has information about the crime, please share what is known.