Judy Faye Stalcup, 60, of West Paducah, Kentucky, was shot and killed at her home on Noble Road on the evening of July 10, 2019. Deputies from the McCracken County Sheriff’s Office found her with a gunshot wound; she was taken to a local hospital but died of her injuries. The only other person at the residence that evening was her ex-husband, Anthony Stalcup, who was still living with her.

Anthony Stalcup first told investigators Judy had taken her own life, then changed his account and said the shooting was an accident. Those inconsistencies prompted his arrest the same night. A grand jury later indicted him for murder and for possession of a handgun by a convicted felon. At trial a jury found him guilty of Judy’s murder; he also pleaded guilty to being a felon in possession of a handgun and was sentenced to a total of forty-three years in prison. An appeal of the murder conviction was filed and the original verdict was upheld.

If anyone knew Judy, her routines, or what happened at the Noble Road residence that night, please share information that could help complete the picture.