Phillip Martin Smith, 61, of Guthrie, Oklahoma, was last seen on September 5, 2020. He has graying hair, blue eyes and a prosthetic right eye. Tattoos noted in reports include the names Nichole, Kaylee and Katrina on his hands and several horse head images on his arms, including a black stallion with two ribbons. Two days after he was last seen his car was found abandoned with its hood up.

Investigators later learned Smith disappeared along with another man, Frederick Mitchell. Multiple informants told authorities both men may have been killed, alleging the killings were ordered by Phillip’s brother, Mikell Bulldog Smith, who is serving time in an Oklahoma prison for three murders. Informants said the men were invited to a party at a two-and-a-half-acre compound in Logan County known as the bully farm, and were killed there. Bone fragments were recovered at three locations tied to the inquiry: the bully farm, a second site about half a mile away, and an oil field lease road near Luther.

No charges have been filed and investigators, including the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation and the Logan County Sheriff’s Office, continue to seek information. If anyone knew Phillip, saw his car after September 5, 2020, or has information about the bully farm or the locations where bone fragments were found, please come forward.