Timothy Braddy was 22 when he disappeared from Bellingham, Washington, after a party on Friday, January 21, 1994, along with his brother Frankie Braddy and roommates Korina Rodriguez and Samantha Ham. Reports say they mentioned rock climbing but are believed instead to have gone to Chuckanut Bay and taken two 12-foot skiffs.

A car loaned to the brothers was found abandoned on Chuckanut Shore Road near a residence from which two skiffs had been reported stolen. One skiff washed ashore in Teddy Bear Cove and a woman’s jacket was recovered in the water, but the four were never found despite searches by the Coast Guard and local authorities.

The prevailing theory is a boating accident on rough water, but the exact fate of the group remains unknown.