Jeremy Garnsey was 21 and a new father when he disappeared from Lyons Falls, New York, on the evening of November 17, 2004. He had been given a ride from work and was dropped off on McAlpine Street; after that he was never seen again.

He left behind his girlfriend and their newborn and reportedly took none of his personal belongings or identification. In the days after his disappearance family, law enforcement and community volunteers searched nearby forests and rivers but found no clues. His last-known clothing was a dark blue American Choppers hat, a yellow jacket over two pullover sweatshirts, olive green khaki work pants and work shoes.

There is no public resolution to the case and the investigation remains open. If anyone in Lyons Falls on November 17, 2004, remembers seeing Jeremy or has information that could help, please come forward.