Donald L. Rutter, a 32-year-old White man from Burlington, West Virginia, was found shot to death at his Beaver Run Road residence on the morning of November 18, 2019. His death was part of a double homicide; 25-year-old Destiny C. Foster of Burlington was also shot and later died at a hospital.

Investigators from the Mineral County Sheriff’s Department, the Potomac Highlands Narcotics and Violent Crimes Task Force, and the Jefferson County Special Response Team worked the case. Arrests followed quickly: Jimmey Lee Lambert, 33, was taken into custody in Shenandoah Junction on November 19, 2019, and Michael Paul Duncan, 29, was arrested in Capon Bridge by Hampshire County deputies on November 21, 2019. Both men were charged with two counts of first-degree murder; Lambert was held without bail.

No motive had been released while the investigation continued. Does anyone have information about Rutter, Foster, or the events around November 18, 2019 that could help investigators?