A dispute over a hunting lease on a remote dirt road near Williamsburg, West Virginia, ended in the deaths of a married couple. Jennifer Thomas, 34, and her husband Jeremiah Thomas were shot and killed on Friday, November 29, 2019, during a confrontation with members of a local hunting club on property near the Greenbrier and Nicholas County line. The argument escalated outside the vehicles at about 4:30 p.m., and one club member, Terri Storer, produced a 9mm Ruger handgun and fired multiple shots that fatally wounded both Jennifer and Jeremiah.

Emergency personnel found the couple on Coleman Road and they were pronounced dead at the scene. The West Virginia State Police identified Storer and another person, Randy Barnhart, as involved; a grand jury later indicted Storer on two counts of murder and Barnhart on two counts of accessory after the fact. After a weeklong trial, a Greenbrier County jury returned guilty verdicts against Terri Storer on two counts of first-degree murder in January 2024, and she was held at Southern Regional Jail awaiting sentencing.

Did anyone in the area have contact with Jennifer or Jeremiah around November 29, 2019, or know details about the hunting lease dispute?