Peyton Nicholas Simpson was 25 when he was fatally shot at a residence in the 3000 block of 5th Avenue in Huntington, West Virginia, on the afternoon of Monday, October 25, 2021. Huntington Police officers found his body when they arrived; detectives then interviewed several people who had been at the scene and identified a potential suspect. In the days after the shooting no charges were filed and no name was released publicly.

Friends and family remembered Simpson as fiercely loyal with a big heart, a sharp sense of humor and a smile that could light a room. His sudden death left a profound void for those close to him. If anyone who knew Peyton or who was in that neighborhood that afternoon has information that could help the investigation, please share what you remember.