Robert L. Throckmorton, 51, disappeared from Waverly, West Virginia in May 2022. His family reported him missing and the case remained unresolved until investigators developed leads that focused on his girlfriend’s residence the following year.

During a search of Melody Ann Anderson’s home, she confessed to killing Throckmorton and burying his body on the property. His remains were recovered on April 22, 2023. Anderson told authorities the shooting occurred after Throckmorton allegedly attempted to sexually assault her; she said she retrieved a gun, concealed it under her pillow, and shot him in the head when he returned to the room and tried to force himself on her.

Anderson, then 50, was arrested and charged with murder and concealment of a deceased human body. Reports also indicate she used Throckmorton’s veterans benefit card for purchases after his death. Anyone who knew Robert, Melody, or who has information about their relationship or the events in May 2022 is asked to come forward.