On the morning of December 26, 2020, a violent confrontation at a Town Fair Tire on Boston Post Road in Orange, Connecticut, left 27-year-old Joshua Figueroa dead. Police found Figueroa, a lifelong New Haven resident and Hillhouse High School graduate, in a service bay with multiple gunshot wounds; he was pronounced dead at the scene.

Investigators focused on 24-year-old employee Terrance Allen after reports that a dispute began the night before when Allen arranged to buy marijuana from Figueroa. Police say Figueroa had been showing a handgun during that transaction and Allen took the gun, prompting a later confrontation at the shop. Witnesses say Allen shot Figueroa multiple times in the service garage, then fled; he was arrested the same day at a Branford hotel.

Charges were later upgraded to include murder, tampering with physical evidence, and criminal possession of a firearm. Bond was set at over $1 million and Allen has remained in custody. If anyone has information about the events on December 25–26, 2020, please come forward.