Kacie Rene Woody was a 13-year-old girl from Holland, Arkansas, who disappeared from her home on the evening of December 3, 2002, while her father, a police officer, was at work and she was alone. Kacie had been active in online chat rooms and had formed a friendship with someone calling himself Dave Fagen, who told her he was 17. Friends noticed she stopped responding to instant messages that night and reported her missing.

Investigators traced phone records linking calls to the Woody home to David Leslie Fuller of La Mesa, California. Fuller, who posed as a teenager online, had traveled to Arkansas and rented a minivan and a storage unit in Conway. On December 4, 2002, authorities approached the storage unit; a single gunshot was heard inside, and both Kacie and Fuller were found dead. Evidence indicated Kacie was shot and had been sexually assaulted; Fuller was identified as the only suspect in her abduction and killing.

Did anyone who knew Kacie or who used the same chat rooms remember interactions with Dave Fagen or other unusual messages that night?