In the early hours of January 30, 2018, Joseph Kohler III, 34, of Johnstown was found dead on the grounds of the former Dominican Retreat House in Cheltenham, Pennsylvania, with a gunshot wound to his upper chest. Kohler had driven to the Philadelphia area a few days earlier and was seen with 24-year-old Antonio Lindsay in the hours before the shooting. Witnesses reported the two walked up a hill on the retreat property, after which gunshots were heard; Lindsay was later seen returning to a car alone before it left.

Investigators say witnesses told them Lindsay blamed Kohler for a recent arrest in which Lindsay was found with a significant amount of heroin. An arrest warrant for Lindsay was issued on February 8, 2018, and he was taken into custody in Philadelphia on March 1, 2018. He was charged with first-degree murder, third-degree murder, and related offenses, and was denied bail. Following trial, Lindsay was convicted of third-degree murder and related offenses and was sentenced to thirty-one to sixty-two years in prison. The 2020 appeal of his sentence was denied.

Does anyone have information about Kohler’s movements in the days before January 30 or about the encounter on the retreat property?