Connor Mays was 16 when he was fatally shot inside a home on the 300 block of Third Street in the Village of Midway, Conewago Township, on the afternoon of Sunday, February 19, 2023, around 2 p.m. A witness who was in the house with Connor said Connor went downstairs after hearing someone enter through a window. That witness then followed and encountered a physical altercation between Connor and another man; the witness reported seeing the man draw a handgun and fire multiple shots.

A Conewago Township police officer who responded found Connor unresponsive just inside the door; he was pronounced dead at the scene. Investigators said Connor and the suspect knew each other and that there had been animosity between them before the shooting. Police identified the shooter as 21-year-old David C. Galemore of Hanover, who was taken into custody and initially charged with criminal homicide.

Galemore later pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of involuntary manslaughter and was sentenced to two to four years in a state prison. Does anyone who knew Connor or who was in the Midway area that afternoon have information to share?