In the early hours of May 6, 2024, gunfire on a porch at Rialto and Hollenbeck Streets in Rochester, New York, left 43-year-old Timothy Chealey dead. He was pronounced at the scene with gunshot wounds. A second victim, 46-year-old Shatina Jones of Buffalo, was found wounded and later died at a hospital; a man in his 20s suffered non-life-threatening injuries.

Police say the shooting followed an earlier altercation at a concert at the Blue Cross Arena. After the show, a group connected to that dispute gathered on Rialto Street and, according to authorities, 23-year-old Jermaine Williams allegedly approached and fired more than a dozen shots into the group. The attack was described as targeted.

Williams was located in Niagara Falls and arrested on May 31 by the U.S. Marshals Violent Felony Fugitive Task Force. He was returned to Rochester and charged with two counts of second-degree murder; he pleaded not guilty at a June 1 arraignment and was remanded without bail. Prosecutors said additional charges could be sought. If anyone has information about the incident or knew Timothy Chealey, please come forward.