In the pre-dawn hours of May 28, 2024, gunfire struck a vehicle that had just entered the parking lot at the Sleepy Hollow Apartment Complex on Terri Lane in Monticello, New York. Officers who responded to a 911 call shortly after 12:30 a.m. found 48-year-old Amy Redmond of Smallwood and an adult man inside the vehicle, both with gunshot wounds. Redmond was taken to Garnet Catskill Medical Center in Harris and pronounced dead; the male victim was transported to Garnet Orange Medical Center with serious injuries.

The New York State Police took over the investigation with assistance from the Village of Monticello Police and the Sullivan County District Attorney’s Office. Authorities have asked the public for information and offered confidential tips. The motive and identity of the shooter are not described in the report; the inquiry remains active.

If anyone saw the vehicle arriving at the Sleepy Hollow complex that night or has information about who might have fired on it, please come forward.