Carley Elbert, 32, of Sewell, New Jersey, was shot in the head and killed in the pre-dawn hours of August 1, 2024. Carley had recently gone into remission from mast cell disease and was described by her family as a loving person with a quirky sense of humor who had been pursuing music as an aspiring freestyle rapper. Police found her unconscious and pronounced her dead at the scene on a jetty near the Flagship Resort on the Atlantic City boardwalk; her friend, 29-year-old Kamille Stewart of Pleasantville, was also shot in the head, found conscious, and taken to a local medical center.

Surveillance footage showed three men and two women walking onto the boardwalk around 2 a.m., with only the three men returning to a car about 20 minutes later. A tip from Carley’s mother, who had been tracking her daughter’s phone, led investigators to an address on Mulberry Street in Philadelphia, where three men were arrested the same day. Gregg Page, 34, was identified as the primary suspect and later faced murder, attempted murder, and weapons charges; brothers Ryan Schenck, 30, and Ramir Schenck, 27, were charged with hindering apprehension.

An Atlantic County grand jury indicted all three in October 2024.

If anyone knew Carley, Kamille, or saw activity on the Atlantic City boardwalk that night, please come forward with what was observed.