Aonesty Selby was reported missing by her family on January 11, 2023, one day after her 18th birthday. Described as bubbly and outgoing with plans to become a cosmetologist, she was found dead on a remote logging path in Isle of Wight County on January 13, 2023, after a friend used a phone ping to help locate her. An autopsy confirmed she died of a single gunshot wound.

Investigators traced her movements to an Uber ride to Newport News, where she went to meet 21-year-old Andarius McClelland. McClelland told police the two had been dating on and off for a couple of months and later admitted to shooting Selby during an argument, then fleeing the scene. He was arrested January 17, 2023, and charged with second-degree murder and the use of a firearm in the commission of a felony.

In July 2025 McClelland pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and use of a firearm, with a first-degree murder charge dropped; he faces a maximum of 43 years and is scheduled for sentencing in November. If anyone knew Aonesty or has information about her movements that week, please share what is known.