Tony Pierrelouis, 24, was shot to death on April 16, 2005, near the Calypso Café in the 1600 block of Mill Street in Tallahassee. Witnesses said a vehicle pulled up, an argument erupted between Tony and an occupant, and the dispute quickly escalated to gunfire that fatally struck him.

When police arrived most witnesses had already left, which complicated the initial investigation. The case remains unsolved and the Tallahassee Police Department’s Cold Case Unit is actively reviewing evidence and following up on potential leads. Authorities have repeatedly appealed to the public for help, stressing that even small details could assist the investigation and bring closure to Tony’s family.

If anyone was near Mill Street on April 16, 2005, or has information about the vehicle or occupants involved, please contact the Tallahassee Police Department’s Cold Case Unit.