A party on Carbondale Drive in Oak Grove, Kentucky, turned deadly on May 25, 2024. During the gathering, 21-year-old Isaiah Enoch Henry McCoy was shot in the chest, privately taken to Jennie Stuart Health, and died at the hospital. An obituary described him as a factory worker and a member of Wings of Faith who enjoyed music, gaming, basketball, and football and was remembered as a cherished big brother and cousin.

The Oak Grove Police Department, with help from the Christian County Sheriff’s Office, arrested a juvenile the next day on a murder charge; court filings later identified the suspect as Oziya Narcisse. Pretrial hearings have been delayed while parties wait for the final autopsy report and other medical records and because scheduling conflicts with the medical examiner and arranging for another minor witness to return to Kentucky have postponed the trial.

Did anyone who attended that party or knew Isaiah notice anything unusual that night?